Sunday, 10 March 2019

The show goes on

Today's lesson is as follows:

1.


2.


Footy is a strange beast. The game started with my daughter (who I'd exiled to another room with a laptop and Netflix while watching the first part of the doubleheader) declaring she doesn't like footy, and ended with her yelling at the TV along with me, before the siren went and she rejoined the Anti Football League because "they blow a siren". Easy come easy go.

Programming two Melbourne games in a row was a wonderful concept on paper, until I came out of the first game flat as a tack and suspicious of what's to come across the next 20 something weeks. To recover some sort of focus instead of spending the next two hours crying about James Harmes' finger, I took an hour's rest before tucking into this. Especially fully expecting further disappointment from the women playing to stay alive in a criminally unbalanced competition. I won't say memories of the fiasco against the Bulldogs last year still traumatise me, but they were front of mind from first bounce to last.

The game started with a classic administrative farce, as the Bulldogs tried starting two players on the ground who'd been listed on the bench. First an exasperated AFL official pulled one of them up, then realised a second was out there as well. Considering all the other pissweak things frees get paid for it's unusual that we got nothing for the Dogs trying to illegally sneak two players into their starting 16.

All that late re-positioning must have left the Footscray players uncertain about where they were supposed to stand, because within a few a seconds Aleisha Newman was running onto a kick over the top into space. It just left her too much angle to bend it back from, but what's a Melbourne AFLW game without blowing early opportunities? See almost the entire first quarter, including Kate Hore doing the first leg of her Earl Spalding routine for the second behind.

All the play was down our end, but following the usual script we wasted numerous chances to kick a goal. When you have a dominant ruck and a strong midfield it's doubling wasteful not getting the ball back into the middle so they can take advantage. Same goes for the men, and if we had an eSports team they'd probably spend their entire time going the wrong way through the last level of Super Mario and being told the Princess is in another castle.

With the Dogs marooned on 0.0 it was reminiscent of Fremantle last year, where we squashed them flat in the first quarter but didn't put the game away and lost. After kicking two points of her own, Hore set up Scott to spray one as well and we were 0.5. For first time viewers, they weren't feeling the pressure of having to maintain our percentage - because even after winning by a point it has been removed as a factor in last round calculations - this is how we play every week.

After being in everything early, Hore switched to creator for the first goal. She won a holding the ball free, then bombed it to the top of the square for Tegan Cunningham to walk through the defenders and take a towering mark. After watching the men try to do that exact same move several dozen times earlier in the afternoon it was nice that somebody finally pulled it off successfully.

That was the only goal of the first quarter, but an 11-0 lead was a decent platform to work with when a win was all that mattered. So naturally we conceded the reply within 90 seconds of the second quarter, and for all the whinging about umpiring it was from the most obvious push in the back since evolution delivered arms to humans. In another parallel between the genders I felt a lot more comfortable when we kept the ball as far as from the backline as possible.

Then a dumb 50 levelled the scores and I decided - as a coping strategy - that even after two narrow losses to sides above us we didn't deserve to make the finals. It's a generally good side that plays well most of the time, and there would have been no call to sack the coach even if we had lost, but when you miss so many scoring opportunities it's hard to consider yourself unlucky. As if telepathically transferred back in time by 40 minutes (including fast-forwarding through quarter time) this brief period of misery generated a goal, with Newman flicking a handball to Paxman for the lead.

Nearly conceding a goal the umpire missing a blatant throw out of the middle threatened to turn me feral again, before a strong saving mark in front of goal by Patterson stopped me in my tracks. The lead didn't last long anyway, they had a shot on goal that fell short and in the most traditional MFC fashion everyone missed rushing it through, allowing the Dogs player who'd been flattened by her teammate minute before to score from a mark, then clutch at her neck like she'd done it crippled.

Then with 30 seconds left (Lady DemonTime) the Dogs got their fourth goal from five inside 50s via further persecution from the Emerald Isle after Irishwomen gave us so much trouble last week. That must have been some kind of world record scoring ratio. Outrageously they had another shot after the siren, but we were saved from the goal that would have ultimately sunk us by a horrible shank.

Can't help but think the half time feeling in our rooms was "oh shit, here we go again". An atmosphere not helped by the Bulldogs carrying on unchallenged after half time and kicking the next goal too. It was a fine line between survival and disaster, with Maddie Gay's snap around the corner bouncing in the square and almost sitting up to be rushed through. For supporters of conspiracy we were also about 17-5 down in the free kick count.

Just as we reduced the margin to six again there was almost another goal line stuff up, with only the barest of touches rushing the ball when nobody had thought to jump at it. This turned the game, creating the opportunity for Eden Zanker to kick the best set shot in the history of Melbourne AFLW, from 40 metres out on the boundary. This left us one point behind at the last change, and we were set for the most terrifying thing of all for followers of this side - a close game.

Anyone who thought Zanker's goal would be a team lifter was temporarily put back in their box when the Dogs got the first of the last quarter. If we could repeat our dominance of the first quarter we might have overtaken their seven point margin in behinds. The first two legs of the behind powered comeback were completed, handily leaving us five behind and a chance at pulling off the ultimate footy steal, the sort of turnaround that makes you think whoever decided it would be six for a goal and one for a behind was a promotional genius.

In the same 'all or nothing' situation against the Bulldogs last year we were the ones in front until the late goal, and thank christ the script was reversed here. Cunningham's strong mark was one thing, but she's a 50/50 proposition from a set shot so I still had heart in mouth until she delivered the stone cold finish to put us ahead.
Now it was our chance to do a cover version of last year and blow the lead. Via Junior repeating that the umpire was "a wanker" when I got excited and yelled it out, the Dogs went forward and camped the ball in their forward line until the last minute. I couldn't imagine any scenario in which we didn't concede a point, draw the game and get eliminated from the finals race a week early. The team had alternative ideas, pulling out a double tough defensive effort that kept the Dogs at bay, and like Brisbane 2009 we weathered the storm, extracted the ball from the precipice of death, and were actually storming into goal when the siren went. Well bugger me that was unexpected.

Footy is good because the close finishes have so many variables that you don't get in other sports. Obviously a soccer team scoring two goals in injury time or basketballers sinking threes on the buzzer are good, but instead of trying to rope internationals into playing AFLX they should just cut up the last two minutes of every game decided by under a goal in the last 15 years and airdrop them over Shanghai.

We live to fight again.

2019 Daisy Pearce Medal
5 - Karen Paxman
4 - Elise O'Dea
3 - Tegan Cunningham
2 - Maddie/Maddy/Maddison Gay
1 - Lauren Pearce

Leaderboard
With either one, two or three games to play it's bad news for those who hoped a ruck would win one of the major awards for the first time. Paxy hit the lead, still plenty of time to play (we hope) for Pearce to topple her.

19 - Karen Paxman
18 - Lauren Pearce
13 - Elise O'Dea
9 - Tegan Cunningham
7 - Maddison Gay/Lily Mithen
4 - Harriet Cordner, Aleisha Newman
3 - Bianca Jakobsson
2 - Tyla Hanks, Kate Hore, Eden Zanker


Ms. Bradbury Plan (updated Sunday afternoon)
Consistent with the rest of the rushed, ill-thought out, and poorly researched posts of this pre-season I initially thought our percentage would  mean an in vs out game against the Crows.

If I'd done my maths I'd have discovered that we needed Adelaide to beat GWS by as little as possible today to keep their percentage within range. Consistent with our game against them, the Giants kept it close for a while before toppling over like a ferry in a typhoon. Now we've got to win by 5-6 goals, which is simply not going to happen.

Even if it does a draw in the Roos/Dockers game would put both through, and in a low scoring competition wouldn't that be something worthy of referral to the newly formed Sport Integrity Australia? After all they will play after our game and know exactly what needs to be done...

Meanwhile, over in the infamous Conference B, Geelong are top with a percentage of 74.2. Good on you AFL.

Next Week
After a week indoors where players were able to hit spectacular long range goals, it's back to the variable breezes of Casey Fields for our latest attempt at making the finals. On the form of the last two weeks beating Adelaide is unlikely, but we've got right up for two big games against Freo and North before falling just short so I'm not ruling it out. After winning by the narrowest of margins here you can pretty much lock in a heartbreaking defeat.

Final Thoughts
Put the Zanker and Cunningham goals at either end of the 2019 AFLW highlights tape. When set shots like that are going in regularly even the hate-watching wankers will struggle to find a problem with women playing (semi) professional footy.

Panic on the streets of Cranbourne

We've put in an injury-riddled pre-season shocker against a team that has been no good for years. Contact your broker and dump every MFC share you hold before it's too late, because by Tuesday morning you won't be able to walk down Collins Street without somebody wearing red and blue landing on you.

Alternatively, take a deep breath, remember that the pre-season is only a rough guide to what happens next, and save all your anxiety for 2012 tribute day against Port at the MCG in Round 1.

As usual I'm taking the middle course between the people dying to hit the button a pre-emptive nuclear strike, and those enjoying an Elon Musk openly puffing on a scoob level of relaxation. There wasn't much to take out of today, but nor was it worth drinking hemlock over.

It certainly wasn't a good performance, and we were lucky to lose by single digits. Many players emerged either battered, bruised, whatever the hell happened to Jay Kennedy-Harris, and in one case with their finger fractured to the point where it was sticking out of the skin BUT if I ever get around to publishing my pre-season preview you'll see I think the Lions are a comfortably mid-table side so it's not the catastrophe it would have been a year ago. In fact, it was a lot like beating the Bulldogs three years ago in Craigieburn (of all places) . Team just emerging from the soup beats finalist, everyone gets a bit excited, and hopefully if we only finish 7th we'll go on to win the flag too.

The only concession I'll give to the people who'll go right over the top about this and start getting wearing "the end is nigh" sandwich boards is that it's an even season with any number of contenders for a flag, because at this stage no way we beat Hawthorn '88 or Essendon '00 juggernaut teams. It could be an opportunity to unexpectedly blag our way through to a Grand Final like we should have in the finely balanced 2004 season, but while it might be a blessing that the competition is free of superteams it's probably going to be a curse that the middle of the table will be so tight. Last year four teams went 12-10 and missed the finals, and this year promises to be even more confusing. You'd think we'd be well clear of the pack, but if you too saw the transition from '98 to '99, '00 to '01, and especially '02 to '03 you'll know not to take anything for granted.

Before slipping back into The Fear, I choose to look at the positives. Namely Viney, Jones and Melksham surviving Casey's easy win over the Lions reserves. It promises to be a big year for Casey, with their coach threatening to literally tear the rest of the league a new one:


Not sure what Jones' role is this year, but we could have definitely done with Viney and Milkshake . The usual suspects did their bit in the midfield, but overall it was down on its usual performance. Melksham provides some semblance of a half-forward line, the likes of which were completely absent at Casey. He's also something of a crumbing threat, another feature that went out the window as we left the Melbourne metropolitan area. Then again, right before this North played a game of such low intensity that it would be an insult to call it bruise free football and they're obviously not going to do that again in the real stuff so who knows what to make of any of it. I admire the people who don't even bother watching until premiership points are at stake.

As a tribute to the AFLW game coming up immediately after, we pinched a move directly from their playbook and opened the game with a string of inside 50s that delivered no result, before conceding the first. Only the truly demented seriously fret about letting the opening goal at any time, let alone in this game, but looking back after knowing the result the ease of it was right to set off a few alarms. It took a smart handball from surprise forward Joel Smith to the new Mr. Total Football Bayley Fritsch - who just randomly appears in different parts of the grounds like a holy apparition - to get us going. Fritsch celebrated his return to Casey as a fully-fledged senior playing by rifling through a goal through off a couple of steps. And all was well with the world for a bit.

When this was followed by even more surprise forward Jayden Hunt leading to a perfect vandenBerg kick for the second I did the most foolish thing possible when watching a Melbourne game and relaxed. Hunt got a second, but not before his old chums in defence went through five minutes of playing like they were escaping a natural disaster.

Oscar McDonald was the face of the defence's woes, burnt off for their first goal after a wank-handed attempt at tackling, barely getting away with a shit kick, then gifting Brisbane's second by punching the ball with one arm and putting Eric Hipwood in a headlock with the other. He was immediately removed from that duel, and could be removed from the seniors if he carries on like this. I know he's a popular whipping boy so it feels cruel to mention that our third goal came from him dropping the ball in a tackle, but it happened. Anal-Bullet was another of the 2018 finals crowd having a shocker, back to those very wobbly days early last year when he barely hung on to his spot in the team.

After the all at sea defence cracked and let the Lions walk one in unchallenged, we replied via a free for a push on Weideman that was about 95% less severe than an unpunished one he'd copped five minutes earlier. The umpiring Wheel of Decisions is back for 2019, usually landing against Melbourne or [outsiders - insert your team here].

There was less doubt about the incident that immediately cancelled Weid's goal, with vandenBerg responding to his second holding the ball of the quarter by simultaneously drawing the umpire's attention yelling at him and punching Lachie Neale in the tit as he ran past to give away a no argument 50. I understand White Line Fever, but it was the stupidest thing you'll ever see. He'll either be fined upwards of a thousand bucks or miss Round 1 for the sake of petulance in the first quarter of a practice match. I know players are going to get reported in the play for big bumps or swingin' arms, but this was so pointless the vandWagon should have been parked for the rest of the quarter.

Ironically, AVB was physically involved in their seventh goal as well. His perfectly legal bump to an opponent caused the guy to try and milk a free kick with acting so poor even the umpire couldn't be sucked in, but leading to the ball bouncing past to a player who finished it. We were lucky not to wear an eighth immediately after, with Hibberd refusing to accept that the quarter was in its final minutes and spitting in the face of DemonTime by going for a run through defence that was fraught with danger. It was an apt way to end a decidedly ropey looking quarter, with the only comfort being Gawn marking everything that came near, Petracca's doing soild work around the ball, and the fact that at the same stage last week we were a similar margin ahead of Richmond and thought we'd win the flag unchallenged.

In most ways the second quarter was our best. It certainly was from a scoring perspective. For injuries it was a disaster. First the inevitable major pre-season injury to a senior player, as like a bullet from a book depository JFK was cut down unexpectedly, landing awkwardly and causing his knee to do things no healthy knee should. Off he went on the stretcher, with the assumption that it was either an ACL or a broken leg and he'd never be seen again, only to be pictured walking around the rooms 30 minutes later. I'll wait for the test results before hailing his miracle recovery, he wouldn't be the first knee victim to be on his feet around shortly after the injury and still end up out for a year. Look at Jake Lever, he walked off like he had a minor complaint and now isn't scheduled to return until about Round 10.

Next thing you knew Harmes was fracturing his finger(s), and if I knew what JLT did I'd boycott them. A straight dislocation or break and he'd have been back for Round 1, now he's probably going to need surgery and will be in all sorts for the opening game. Good thing we've got Viney to roll back in, but you'd still rather both of them. (Sunday update - now it appears Harmes will play Round 1. I'm a worse injury reporter than Brian Taylor). Then there's Kennedy-Harris, who may yet go one better than the original JFK and survive the sniper's bullet but probably wasn't in the Round 1 frame anyway. This is not to denigrate his performances this pre-season, the first thing I thought when he hit the deck was what a shame it was for it all to come to a screaming halt when he'd been playing pretty well.

Meanwhile, Preuss did something to his groin the seconds, and with Dr. Phil Nietzchke already out for the season with a knee injury can I point out that it's not too late to ring Aspley and get Jake Spencer back to a) be an emergency ruck option, and b) qualify for his life membership. In the year that the two ruckmen setup returns we're risking disaster only carrying two seasoned options on the list + Weideman (!?) and Keilty (!!!?) as the backups. Spencer may not be your cup of tea, and I don't think anyone likes him as much as me, but having seen how Preuss went solo last week I wish there was a Ben Hudson/Jonathan Giles style journeyman we could have parked on the rookie list just in case either of them topple over.

Before we launched our comeback in earnest, the sides traded goals to open the second quarter. After Hunt of all people showed how to lead in the first term, we returned to the obsessive long bombing to the square that gave us all the shits last year. For all the fun we had tonking slurry teams in the middle of the year it still feels that we ended up the highest scoring team in the competition by luck. What if we've got no further attacking improvement in us and the rule changes designed to enhance scoring just help everyone else catch up? Ponder that for the next two weeks if you dare.

The terror bombing of the goal square has got some merit when you're aiming at McDonald, Weideman and probably either Gawn or Preuss, but when you just thump it to the same spot every time don't be surprised that the opposition know exactly where to run the moment the ball comes off the boot. Like how everyone knew Hogan always wanted it kicked over the top, you need some mystery about the forward entries. So far McDonald certainly hasn't looked like taking massive overhead grabs, and he almost spilled one here before narrowly holding on and converting. What happened to the lovely leads he'd do last year? Last week I could buy them being shut down by a top level defence, but he didn't look at all likely here. After a Bradbury Plan inspired truce late in the season, and two finals performances that would have swept anything under the rug (although, the last three quarters against Geelong weren't exactly an attacking masterclass if we're being honest) let my war on our forward structures recommence.

It was nice to be creating chances, even if we were blowing them, because it meant keeping the ball away from our defence. If nothing else, we were seeing the value of May in the way he instantly shut Hipwood down after those first two goals. He got the bulk of his possessions in the second half, but the only people counting kicks for key defenders are Supercoach Wankers. He was solid, Jetta was lively against Charlie Cameron and Hibberd got a lot of kicks but otherwise there was nothing to fill me with confidence that we're going to improve from being the 9th best defensive side in the league. It wasn't all the fault of the backmen, a lot of it was how often and how easily the ball went down there. I'd almost have Frost over Oscar for Round 1 and the quicker they can work out a replacement for Lewis the better. Like the lost third McDonald brother a couple of high profile blunders are all people remember from his usually on target disposals, but its the ease opposition players go around him that worries me.

Nevertheless, for all this misery Spargo took advantage of strong work by Gawn and the Richmond in Shepparton style comeback was on. At least until Jarryd Lyons - who couldn't get a game at the rock bottom Gold Coast but was content to thump us - pissed off Jetta for a mark and his first of four goals to take their score across 50 midway through the second quarter. It was only a temporary steadier (though there would be much more steadying to come), as the impressive Joel Smith first kicked one of his own, then set up another by standing up in a marking contest, then giving to an Oliver/Brayshaw combination for the goal.

The ball movement between the arcs was still pretty good, but our kicking inside 50 was almost as bad as our defending, and in the first half we were breaking even in the clearances at best before losing them comfortably by the end. Harmes' smashed digit was a factor, but it wasn't the only thing keeping us down. When Petracca executed the first lead since the first quarter to mark 50 metres out I thought "what a waste, may as well have been somebody who can kick straight", but against all odds he put it through.

It was going almost dead on to the script of last week, the team who did all the scoring early packed up in the second quarter and gave the opposition a second life. In Shepparton the half ended as a draw, this time we'd have been ahead if it wasn't for a goal created from an blatant throw that went unpaid. Though to be fair to the umpire with the white cane and assistance dog, Brisbane should never have had the ball down there to begin with after deciding to pack up and start chipping the ball around in defence two minutes before the end of the quarter.

After a half time break where I realised how much I enjoyed having access to the 60x fast forward button, my actions betrayed secretly wanting to win when 15 seconds into the third the ball flew through a crowd to unexpectedly land in the arms of a Brisbane forward, I yelled "FUCK" and punched the couch. It was such a bullshit goal to concede that I've been upset at it happening to any team in the history of the club, including Fourths, Thirds, Seconds, Lightning Premiership and AFLX squads. Shortly after Angus Brayshaw appeared to kick the ball into his own face, just the sort of novelty injury that's likely to end in him retiring from another major concussion.

The pointless, unrewarded dumping kicks inside 50 continued without anyone looking even half likely to crumb until Smith of all people grabbed one off a pack and snapped around the corner. I thought it was a gag when they put him in the forward line as the Preliminary Final went tits up but he's showing plenty down there. Still, be wary of pre-season form. Remember the year Emo Maric was set to be a breakout star based on two practice matches, got dropped after two games and ended up delisted?

On an otherwise dud day, McSizzle got his second shot at goal from one of the great administrative frees. From a boundary throw-in the ball flew over the ruckmen, and the Brisbane player behind them who it practically landed on was pinched for touching it. It was correct application of a rule that should be shot, buried in a shallow grave and covered in lime. Presumably once it cleared the nominated ruckmen the other 36 players on the ground were meant to run away like a live hand grenade had been tossed into their midst. What if the rucks collided with each other and went to ground, would everyone have to wait for one of them to beat the 10 count and get to the ball before the game could continue? What a farce.

McDonald missed what should have been a sitter for him, and by three quarter time the game diverged from the path of last week by Stuart Dew's mate Lyons kicking a third and fourth to put them comfortably ahead again. When the entire plan is built on winning contested ball we'd better either do that all day or take advantage of the chances we do get, and Oliver spurning a doddle of a snap from the top of the square was unfortunate.

The new 50 metre penalty rule is also causing much grief, with the completely unnecessary ability to play-on before reaching the mark leading to players being pinched for getting too close as the ball-carrier is marched to an arbitrary point down the field where he's supposed to take the kick from. In the Port game, one player 'earned' his second 50 by veering left and crashing into the player running next to him. Apparently you're not even allowed to run next to them, so why doesn't the player who conceded the original penalty just piss off somewhere else and let somebody else stand the mark? Either way, what's AFL season without some bonkers interpretation that sets the world alight until Round 4, is forgotten until Round 17 when they go hard on it for a week, and is then shelved for the finals?

With 30 minutes left, a 19 point deficit, players who looked like they were just trying to get to the end without contracting a surprise bout of Lassa fever, and no visible signs of a comeback my only concerns were avoiding more injuries, and Steven May suppressing his natural instinct for clobbering Brisbane players.

Old habits die hard:




I reckon he got lucky and the bump caught the bloke as high as humanely possible on the torso without collecting him in the head. Maybe a light brush of the jaw, but the impact was in the body. Of course, when the Lions take revenge for the time he killed Stef Martin by producing a doctor's report loaded with concussion speculation that'll do him in. Still, it's walking a fine line to be doing that in a pre-season game. If he does get rubbed out then it's buyer beware for signing somebody with a lengthy record of hitting people for the first time since Byron Pickett.

Things looked even more dire when we didn't have an inside 50 for the first five minutes of the quarter, and even that only came courtesy of a Lions switch that eventually ended in a goal. As it went though I had to reassure myself that our players had lost interest after the injuries. Also that it takes some of the heat off us for Round 1 now that all the journos who lost their mind and tipped us to win the flag will probably be queuing to write articles on why Goodwin should be boiled in oil.

If post-injury malaise was to blame - and now we not only had two players out, but Smith, Jetta and Fritsch hobbling and Petracca clutching his wrist to come - that didn't explain being off in the first quarter. I suppose after being in the unusual position of winning a lot of matches recently it was about time we had a couple of learning experiences to keep everyone grounded.

It took about 10 minutes to go across 50 via our own boot, with Smith busting through the pain barrier to get on the end of a lead then kicking out on the full and going back to hobbling around like the elderly. They must have deduced he couldn't make whatever he'd done any worse, because there was no point leaving him out there otherwise. I would have endorsed the Hardwick strategy of playing short if necessary. He soon made amends for that shithouse first kick by putting one through from a free and we inched closer. If this is how he plays with a sore foot then somebody stomp on it in the rooms before every game.

As Petracca grimaced and grabbed at his wrist I was ready to go and start my car in the garage and watch the rest of the game amongst the fumes, only to be stopped in my tracks by a Brayshaw goal that further reduced the margin. The site of Truck delivering a perfect, unencumbered handball frm the middle then convinced me to turn the ignition off and wait until at least half time of Round 1 before contemplating self-harm again.

After veering away from the path of last week, the ghost of JLT Community Series games past returned when our belated tilt at winning cut the margin to two goals. Neal-Bullen cropped up on the end of a scything kick across goal by Gawn, and when he finished the prospect of what would have undoubtedly been the worst win ever was back on the agenda. The brakes temporarily went on when Hunt, back in his traditional role, tried to run around an opponent after a mark, only to find his opposite number having none of it and wrapping him up for holding the ball. Like our forward entries it's no good doing the same thing every time and expecting that other sides don't do their homework.

Somehow we got forward for another, with Smith barely able to leave the square due to his hobbling but still managing to find a fourth. It was a low stakes rerun of Paul Wheatley in the 2005 Elimination Final, and when we find out on Monday that he's out for the season with a crushed ankle I will put a hex on everyone involved with keeping him on the ground. Still, watching him taking an unchallenged mark because his opponent had wandered up the field was a great advertisement for the old school tactic of parking somebody at full forward and not letting them move. If the full forward stays at home how much damage can their opponent do? Enough to lose the chance at having a bloke roaming the forward 50 on his own and kicking easy goals on the break? Probably, but I'd still like to see somebody try it.

Not that winning mattered - which is what you say when you lose unexpectedly - but any chance of completing a storming revival that swept all the dubious stuff under the rug was finished by Oliver giving away a pointless free at the next centre bounce for lightly whacking his opponent in the guts. This is the sort of pointless macho bullshit that does my head in. Speaking of pointless, this was followed by the umpire seemingly paying a free against Mitch Robinson, then waiting for him to lash out at Lewis in frustration before revealing it was his ball anyway. Lottery.

Brisbane's attempts to finish the game were reminiscent of the years where we'd make finishing any close game a terrifying ordeal (e.g. 1859-2018). After we'd unsuccessfully tried to set up the big mark in front of goal about 45 times they nailed one, only for the guy to do a Simon Eishold style shank out on the full. There was still time to score seven and snatch either a win or a worthless draw (P.S - after last week I did a deep dive into non-premiership matches and found one previous pre-season draw, against Sandhurst in 1934. I'm sure your life has been enriched by this knowledge), except immediately after the big shank we handed them another opportunity which they gleefully accepted.

Brayshaw got one on the siren to somehow restrict the margin to single figures, and I faced Casey Fields and for the second week in a row paid thanks to the cosmic forces that stopped me from leaving the house to watch live. I'd like to say I hope that's not happening towards the MCG in a couple of weeks, but I crave the sensation of a real game so will be there in person to see everything we've worked for go up in a puff of smoke OR receive a life-affirming reminder that good times are on the horizon.

Uniform Watch
Not only does the Jaguar logo looks significantly better on the regular colour jumper, it comes up beautifully when compared to random companies like GFG and SOOW as worn by Port and Brisbane. Whoever's got money to spend is welcome, and for all I know SOOW might be 100x more stable than a luxury car manufacturer but it feels like we're carrying an extra, welcome, touch of class. Apparently SOOW (or SO as it's styled) is "about creating trust in how everyday consumers and enterprises share data openly". Which sounds like the sort of company who'll go missing when they get the bill for their second year of sponsorship.

UPDATE - This is the only prediction I was close to getting right all day. Not only did they fail to make year two, they failed to make month four. As the Brisbane Lions CEO probably said "Soow... you're telling me you've gone into administration". They were actually out the door before this game even happened. Maybe the infinity logo signifies how much they owe creditors?

Media Watch
No Dwayne, no Dermott, no content. Except when they showed a Casey player with a full head of hair kicking a goal and identified him as Preuss.

Poor old Nick Riewoldt went with it ASAP while Dunstall and Huddo held back until it was obvious they'd shown A. Random. Still, as close to a perfect commentary combination as you're going to get on Fox, with the shrieking and buffoonery kept to a minimum. Dunstall does himself a disservice acting like a clown on The Bounce when he is actually one of the better special comments men around.

2019 Paul Prymke Plate for Pre-Season Performance votes
5 - Max Gawn
4 - Christian Petracca
3 - Joel Smith
2 - Neville Jetta
1 - Clayton Oliver

Apologies to Brayshaw, Salem and May.

Final leaderboard
Congratulations to Max, who goes back-to-back, becomes the first player ever to win the Plate twice, and ends a two year run of multiple winners. Can he string it across 22 games and become the first ruckman ever to win the Jakovich? The historical record says no.

10 - Max Gawn
7 - Clayton Oliver
6 - Christian Petracca
5 - Angus Brayshaw, Christian Salem
4 - James Harmes, Braydon Preuss
3 - Joel Smith

Coming this week
Almost exactly the same content promised after the Richmond game - an AFLW report and the finalised pre-season preview. The preview has been as good as finished for a week but I thought it was more prudent to wait until all the practice matches were over so it could include any perspective gained this week. Sadly I have gained too much perspective and will probably go back to drape the veil of negativity over it. At least now I can not only factor in Mitch Hannan's mystery injury, but the unwelcome news that Lever might not play until mid-year. Links in all the usual places when complete.

Next week
If you're a male player, nothing. Except for some last minute high risk training sessions where everyone is requested not to turn too sharply and to instantly give up if they feel a twinge anywhere in their body.

The week after
Watched the second half of the Port game, and while they seemed better than expected North's disinterest in doing anything remotely defensive would have made anyone look good. I'm more confident in winning Round 1 then I am in following with wins in Geelong and Sydney, but against a side who only missed the eight due to an epic collapse and still won 12 games it is anything but a guaranteed win. All those years I moaned about wanting to test ourselves against a good team in Round 1, now expectations are up and I'd be quite happy with playing Gold Coast at home.

Final thoughts
One way or the other everyone except James Harmes will forget this match happened by 6pm on Saturday 23 March. And thank christ for that.

Tuesday, 5 March 2019

Protect and Survive

For all the respect I've got for AFLW, and the enjoyment I get from watching a version of the top flight game that hasn't been turned into a complete wankfest yet, my delayed viewing of the Sunday double-header was always going to start with the men. Watching in reverse led to the danger of the result being blown during the coverage of the Richmond game and the unprecedented scenario of me having to watch when I already knew the result. Fortunately the two competitions live in separate universes, and nobody thought to make reference to us either winning or losing two games on one day. As it turns out we went 1-1, and as I found out later it may as well have been 0-2.

I was comfortable that if the result of this game were somehow blown for me that it would have just been confirming what seemed like an obvious Melbourne win, but those 25 of us who saw the 2017 Blacktown International (?) Sportspark debacle at 5.05pm on a Friday night knew not to take anything for granted. The Giants were no good when they beat us then, and are not much better now. At quarter time the prospect of another shock defeat loomed large, before version three MFCW did what version one should have and won in a landslide. That cost us a spot in the Grand Final, this barely kept our hopes of a semi final berth afloat.

Like so many other games that have ended in grim struggle it started well, with a perfect chain of ball movement landing in the hands of Tegan Cunningham 30 metres directly in front. There was nothing more on-brand for us than her missing it. The best bit about the way it got to her was the umpire missing Karen Paxman's two-handed rugby style throw out of the middle. It was one of few touches Paxman got in the first half, before coming good at the end when we were kicking the GWS' brains in.

Cunningham found her range later for three goals, but her next miss was even more irritating. Players miss easy shots at every level, but in a low scoring competition there's potential to quickly knock the opposition out if you convert. Put an inferior team a couple of goals in the hole at quarter time and fat chance they'll recover. The Giants nearly made us pay full price for the miss, with the acceptable public face of the name C. Bernardi just falling short. We looked flat as a tack, even with Cunningham's second shot. Thank god she started kicking them or somebody was going to get hit again out of frustration.

If we couldn't have Max Gawn in the later game we could at least enjoy his female equivalent Lauren Pearce snaffling goals in a regional location. For once an administrative 50 went in our favour, and though her kick looked horrid off the boot it floated through for the opener. Because there's nothing more footy fans want than deafening music blaring out after goals, this provoked a volume 11 rendition of Sweet Dreams Are Made Of This. Like the guy who wouldn't stop yelling "Let's Go Giants, let's go!" it may have just been that the effects mic was right next to the speaker, or there was a secret government conspiracy to test torture techniques on the 1500 people who'd already braved scorching heat to watch at a ground with not even the slightest bit of visible shade.

The lead was lucky to survive for long, with one of GWS' Irish Experiment (either Cora the Explorer or The Other One) snapping from the top of the square with all the time in the world but missing. Both the Irishwomen were racking up touches at will around the ground in the biggest fix up from the Republic since Pearce Hanley and Niall McKeever helped ruin Round 1, 2012. For fans of the Kingsleys, that was also the day Claye Beams was nominated for a Rising Star before going on to do bugger all for the rest of his career. They bought their first goal locally, with Bernardi running onto her own handball in the square. The set off Roxette's The Look, which I assume was on because it's sung by a woman but is surely actually about something unsavoury.

That was it for first quarter goals, and at 1.2.8 apiece at the first change we didn't look much like a side who'd sunk the nearly unsinkable the week before playing a side with one win against the worst team in the history of AFLW. If we lost Blacktown was going to be labelled the female equivalent of Football Park, a valley of death from which no players emerged unscathed.

Unable to convert set shots, Cunningham instead opted for brute force and kicked the first after the break by holding her opponent at arms' length to kick off the ground. This didn't dampen the enthusiasm of the guy going nuts for the Giants into the microphone. He later wilted in the heat and switched to a one man Giants *clap clap clap* routine, before being overheard having a conversation about rugby league that forced the commentators to talk over him. I was hoping they'd shut up and let us concentrate on what he was saying in case he confessed to a murder.

Watching their full back being dismissed with the greatest of ease put a hole in the Giants' resolve, and they never looked like kicking another goal before Zanker took a strong mark and converted her set shot to extend the gap to 14. That was ultimately the match-winning break we'd spurned with misses in the first quarter. The pressure on the Giants had gone through the roof since quarter time, but despite picking up holding the ball frees up and down the ground we were still unable to throw the knockout punch. On the other hand, the quality of the opposition suggested they wouldn't get the ball inside 50 enough to trouble a 16 point lead.

The killer blow finally came from who else but Fightin' Tegan Cunningham, who ran through a defence in disarray to take the easiest chest mark in history and convert. Good thing too considering Guerin had just missed running into an open goal from her handball. This insulated us against all but the most outrageous comeback, and the only Giant who still believed was the guy screaming nonsense in the crowd.

Even though the game had concluded 18 hours before I was watching I could have still done with a live ladder. Percentage is barely important, but I'd still like to have known where we stood. It would have also confirmed that GWS and their one win were still a chance of making the finals out of the dud Conference B.

Further misery might have been lumped on the locals if the ball sat better for ex-dairy farmer Shelley Scott running into an open goal, but halfway through the quarter the Giants still only had one goal and looked unlikely to even reach 33 points let alone keep us from scoring again. Scott continued to have trouble with the surface, flubbing a bounce running into an open goal.

In the interest of equalisation we did everything possible to get GWS back into the game, after the failed bounce we gave them a chance via two defenders running into each other, then gifted them their second goal from a kick-in disaster. The spirit of Dwayne Russell floated to Blacktown and took on female form when it was said that the umpire was 'sick of going for the behind flag'. Which last time I checked is the same flag used to help signify a goal. Then Leigh Montagna, who is a reasonable second division caller, suggested a Giants player was "finged". I think he meant pinged, but unsure where the F came from.

That goal cut the margin to 16, leaving us to withstand two minutes of pressure before the end of the quarter. It should have been cut to 10, with a shot after the siren assisted by gratuitously unpunished improvement of the angle during the run-in. It fell just short, meaning that we just needed one goal in the last quarter to make sure of victory. Male or female, no Melbourne side is ever immune from a goalless quarter. Recognising we needed a hand, Gay (either Maddison, Maddy or Maddi depending on who you believe) got a freebie from an umpire 50 metres away and kicked the god honest sealer.

It eventually turned into the runaway, crushing win you want against rubbish opposition, but the most pleasing part of it was that there was no major contribution from O'Dea and Paxman only ran riot in the last quarter. Goes to show there's plenty of improvement to be had over the next couple of weeks, and potentially beyond. The safe win was made even safer by Cunningham adding another from distance, and Paxman tapped one in from the line after all the Giants had given up.

The last goal came from a downfield free, with further misery heaped on GWS as it was turned into a 50. Through it went, we went home happy and the season lived. At least the players and people who watched live got to enjoy the feeling of the season being alive for a couple of hours. I checked the scores from other games immediately after the siren, discovered Adelaide had beaten North and ll this effort was wasted.

Banner Watch
Just the usual curtained, iSelect effort from us. On the other side GWS made the frankly defamatory suggestion that 'Winners are grinners. Let's put away the Demons and sinners'. I suspect they were just reaching for a rhyme rather than accusing our players of doing anything outrageous. Either that or popular Sydney religious nutbag Fred Nile had commandeered the cheersquad. Fred would have smashed the screen with his walking stick when the new occasion of 'Mardi Gras Boxing Day' was referenced during the call.

2019 Daisy Pearce Medal
5 - Maddison Gay
4 - Tegan Cunningham
3 - Bianca Jakobsson
2 - Kate Hore
1 - Karen Paxman

Leaderboard
17 - Lauren Pearce
14 - Karen Paxman
9 - Elise O'Dea
7 - Lily Mithen
6 - Tegan Cunningham
5 - Maddison Gay
4 - Harriet Cordner, Aleisha Newman
3 - Bianca Jakobsson
2 - Tyla Hanks, Kate Hore, Eden Zanker

Ms. Bradbury Plan
The North loss has all but put us away. We'd be 70% clear at the top of Conference B(ullshit), but instead sit fourth of five in Group A and it may come down to beating the Crows at Casey in the last round.

Nevertheless, your Ms. Plan for next week:

Geelong d. Fremantle (unlikely, but not impossible)
GWS d. Adelaide (zero chance)
Collingwood d. North (less than zero chance)

If all three of the above fail it sets up a last round where we'd need to topple the Crows, then for North to beat Freo immediately after.

Next Week
The last placed Bulldogs at Docklands, who are finished for this season based on the Conference they've fallen into. Based on that we should beat them, but nothing is certain. At least if we lose it will remove the misery of another last round exit.

Final Thoughts
If the Fremantle or North Melbourne losses taught us anything, this is a team that gets up for the big matches. Well there are two coming up so time to go full barrel and actually win a couple of close ones.

Sheppatitis

It's a sign of growing maturity - at last - that when press-ganged into working in high 30 degree temperatures across a weekend that ended in two Melbourne FC games on the same day I turned up instead of claiming that my Aunt Hortense was dead and staying home to watch. Once, in a time before wall-to-wall coverage of practice matches, I'd have almost certainly not only chucked a sickie but gone to Shepparton and risked being seen on the coverage alive and well. Welcome to mid-life crisis era Demonblog.

The original plan was to avoid scores of either the men's or women's (report to follow) games, and watch when I returned from the other side of regional Victoria on Sunday night. After two and half days in the heat on barely any sleep I lost faith in part of the process about an hour before the AFLW game and unsuccessfully tried to palm it off to a guest reporter. Then after driving home through levels of traffic that would frustrate somebody from Beijing, I arrived home feeling like I'd just escaped being held hostage by Hezbollah and couldn't bring myself to do anything other than sleep.

I'd have powered through if premiership points were on offer, but for a practice match I could prioritise sleep. At least until about 6am when crunts started reversing trucks up and down the street. It wasn't until about 9.30 when I finally conceded that there was no more rest to be had, and that the only thing likely to wake me up was another year of no idea what JLT do or how I'm supposed to take advantage of their services.

The last time I woke up this close to watching a match was Round 9, 2006 I got up at 4.39 for a 4.40pm bounce, then in celebration of Chris Johnson getting four votes stayed up all night before going to work at 5am, driving to Altona Beach to fill in the time and seeing this daubed across a fence:


But enough about me, there was pre-season football to be had. Albeit without about 10 first choice players. Other than Lever and May, missing from those golden September nights (yes coma victims, we have quite recently won finals) were Gawn, Hannan, Hibberd, Jetta, Jones, Lewis, Melksham, Tyson (can't help you there), vandenBerg and Viney. Reasonable outs. Not that Richmond were at full strength either, but they had enough of the highest tier big guns that you might have gotten a bit silly and started thinking these games meant something had we carried on for the last three quarters like the first.

We weren't entirely without quality, led for the first time by Tom McDonald, who couldn't play AFLX a week earlier because he needed surgery but had already recovered in time to play the first of two pre-season games. They might have left him until the second week of the 'series' to make it look a little less cynical. He kicked two goals but risked re-injuring his whatever by kicking shit in frustration at being jumped on and/or over by multiple Richmond defenders.

Captain McSizzle led the team out in the always welcome disco jumper, but as pretty as the Jaguar logo is it looked well out of place on that razzle dazzle jumper. We should have signed them for the classy version of our jumper and SHAGGIN' WAGON for this one.

I think the last time I went through a practice match without being there, watching on TV or listening on the radio is when Liam Jurrah blew his shoulder on some suburban Adelaide gravel pit so I remain grateful as always that these games are broadcast. There was even the unusual scenario of Dermott Brereton seemingly being helpful, providing the interesting stat that Braydon Preuss is the third heaviest senior player ever to play the game. It was implied that this was in a good, man-mountain way, then he spent the first half puffed out and most of the second sitting on the bench. In an attempt to find who the two bulkier players were I discovered this, which suggests he's only the equal sixth biggest on an AFL list this year so maybe DERM was talking from his ringpiece after all.

According to my limited research, this was the first time we'd ever played at Deakin Reserve, after a previous appearance at the Shepparton East Football Ground for a 138-153 thriller against the Saints in 1987. Other local practice matches include a nine goal thrashing by Geelong in 1980, similar from North in Tatura in 1982, and the Ox doing his knee in Albury. Comparatively, returning to the city with a 12 point loss and one minor injury was almost like a win.

The locals rolled out the barrel for this event, parking an ad on the camera side promoting Shepparton as a 'Sporting Event Capital', which was ably demonstrated by a) the sponsor SAND AND GRAVEL, and b) a low brick wall around most of the boundary that opened the prospect of somebody fracturing his skull. In the bits where the wall ended there was a giant gap between advertising hoarding and ground that somebody decided was a good place to let kids sit. Now that they've all survived I'm comfortable with the idea of letting them get up close and personal with real life footy players, but had one of them slid across the line at the wrong angle the kids would have been decimated. An especially serious concern with the alleged third heaviest player since 1897 getting around.

It was our first serious chance to see the latest set of new rules in action, and I know they were softening us up for these ones by floating some real bullshit ideas but the initial reaction was a big fat "meh". Which is about as good as you're going to get from significant changes to the way the game is officiated. The 6-6-6 definitely generated a few opportunities out of the middle but was otherwise inoffensive (except when they stopped the game and issued the teams a stern warning for getting it wrong), and the players cannoning out of the square to play on looked stupid but had no real negative impact.

There's nothing better after a rule change than people declaring it to be a success after five minutes, only for coaches to work out how to negate it by about Round 8, and if the intention of these ones is to increase scoring (and it is) then there would have been a few nervous corporate wankers early. In the first five minutes we conceded the only score, as one wonky holding the ball decision led to Oscar McDonald being thrashed into the post while trying to rush a behind artistically. This was the cue for the scoring to commence in earnest, with Billy Stretch opening the season half-proper (well, more proper than that Collingwood scratch match anyway) by marking a clever Petracca kick at the top of the 50. There was a McDonald involved in this one too, with Stretch burning a perfect McSizzle lead with Napalm before saving himself from the wrath of his temporary captain by converting.

At the other end our defence had a bash, but without Hibberd or Jetta from our finals team there was a distinct lack of poise. Richmond's opening goal was one of several they got from within 10 minutes, and was arguably the fault of the defenders for letting a ball hit the deck unchallenged, but more crucially down to Jack Higgins flying through a crowd to soccer it with no regard for his personal safety. If somebody is willing to die to kick a goal I'll concede without argument.

Our next goal also featured Tom McDonald, this time the subject of a doubling teaming usually only seen in adult features, which allowed Joel Smith to float in and mark. His first foray as a forward against West Coast only came after we'd given up the ghost, but this implied much potential as a medium sized goalkicker. At the moment all the focus is on the talls, including Weideman taking his role as a second ruckman in Gawn's absence seriously but setting up the forward thrust that allowed Sizzle to snatch an intercept handball and snap his first. The debate about whether we should have kept Hogan will go longer than Nic Nat vs Watts (knee injury vs needs tits), but the value I see in McDonald compared to Hogan is that he's better at creating goals out of nothing as well as via the traditional methods.

In trying to avoid all spoilers, or even hints to progress scores, on Sunday afternoon the one time I nearly tripped myself up was when delirious from the heat I flipped open Twitter on my phone and saw one tweet praising Oliver for doing something jaw-droppingly delightful. I've gone back and compared the times and think it can only be this moment, where he was lifted in the air but still managed to find a handball target.

While our period of domination confirmed that Petracca still can't kick set shots for shit, we were reminded that Weideman can, from a mark that fell right into what Gorilla Monsoon would have referred to as his breadbasket. He wasn't spectacular but he did his job, as did most of the forwards without anyone doing anything truly spectacular. The next came from Joel Smith again, after Trent Cotchin gave away a free in the middle, paid his frustration with a 50 for toppling Brayshaw, then walking off the ground in disgust stuffing his mouthguard up his shorts despite the sweaty conditions. At least it was his own plum sweat he'd be consuming later. Waste not, want not.

As I discovered last year when Hawthorn was punting our heads in, watching on tape is fraught with danger because you're always tempted to fast forward when things don't go your way. But other than the dramatic walk out just before our belated comeback against St Kilda I always stay true to watching the game play out in real time. The breaks can get stuffed, this time I had two games to watch and two reviews to write so there was stuff all time for filler content.

The only thing I stopped for was Roos interviewing Goodwin, and even then the only interest was hearing about a former gambling addict being a keen investor in the stock market. I suppose if you can't entirely give up the into the thrills of making and losing money, then stocks force you to slow down and think about what you're doing instead of making $10k on Japanese baseball, then losing it five minutes on the Terang Open mixed doubles. As somebody who also has an addictive personality and has to work had to stuff all sorts of vices away I was left tapping my nose and saying "I know what this bloke is up to". But until he stops being able to coach footy what do I care?

We nearly made it to DemonTime with our four goal lead intact, before going to sleep and letting them kick 1.3 without getting the ball back over half way. In retrospect this was a hint to what was going to happen later, but for now we were making the most of opportunities and extended our lead with two more goals before the break. First Truck showed he can kick great goals as long as he's on the run by waltzing around a defender and sinking one from 50, then immediately out of the middle Garlett pushed his defender towards the dreaded brick wall and kicked a pearler from the pocket. Jeff then went on to completely fuck up his shoulder.

By the end of the quarter there was so much scoring that it's a surprise Gil and Steve Hocking didn't drive across the ground in a hovercraft. We could even afford to concede the last when Dustin Martin played his celebrity card and was allowed to slap Harmes twice around the chops by an umpire standing metres away.

Leading by 22 points against an unruly mixture of premiership players and randoms wasn't worth pausing to see how to buy North Melbourne Grand Final Breakfast tickets, but without 10 of our best players it seemed to confirm we'd beat the piss out of some lowly teams during the year. Whether it translates to playing Richmond when it matters, or indeed to mid-table strugglers Port Adelaide in Round 1 (and after the last time we opened the year against them at the 'G be on guard for a shambles) I don't know, but am confident that we'll wreak havoc on the St Kilda, Carlton and Gold Coast bracket.

The good times continued after the break, with Oliver doing his own version of 6-6-6 by winning the ball from the bounce, then charging forward to be the player who set up 2x AFLX premiership legend Bayley Fritsch (temporarily a forward again) for the eighth goal. Practice match in sweltering conditions or not, it was all getting a bit silly now. Richmond obviously realised this, because by half time they'd kicked five of the next six and were level.

We got away with the absence of Lever from an already edge of your seat backline in the second half of the year (at least until the prelim), but the defence was all over the shop here. There were decent signs from Petty and Hore, but you wouldn't trust this combination with your precious premiership points. Richmond took advantage of keeping the ball away from us to get the next three on a nominal breeze, cutting the margin back to single digits.

This was about the point where Preuss-mania screamed to a halt, struggling mightily when required to play first ruck on his own. It demonstrates more than ever that we're in more trouble than the early settlers in Maximum goes down. They should do good work as a duo, but Max's ability to go all day even when he looks like he's about to die is crucial to his success. Now that ruck duos are back in vogue I'd have rookie listed NEAFL Team of the Year player The Spencil again just in case - also to get him that life membership he was so cruelly denied by one season.

A temporary steadier came via the Oliver/Brayshaw magic duo creating an opportunity for Harmes, which he celebrated with a devil horned salute to heavy metal. Later it was suggested to be some AFLX gag, but let's have none of that spoiling the enjoyment of good, honest, legitimate footy. Harmes' finish was good, but it never happened with the Hamburglar having another sixth sense moment of creating a better outcome by changing his mind halfway through doing something. He is a freak, and his in-play brain patterns should be studied by the government.

Relief from the Tiger onslaught didn't last long as we conceded another goal from the goal line because nobody would rush it. At this stage I had to remind myself that pre-season games don't mean shit, and losing to the reigning minor premier would not automatically mean a dramatic plunge back down the ladder. Then the same mystery player who'd earlier roved his own marking contest to goal kick another, scores were level and I was swearing like a dockworker.

Didn't take long after the half for Richmond to get in front. The key difference was that in front of our goal Astbury and Rance were merrily chopping off attacks, while at the other end Riewoldt was marking ahead of Marty Hore. Nothing against Hore, but with respect to the 10 conceded by Steven May in his last start against Riewoldt, I'd much rather the all-new crisis-free Steven May doing that job by the next time we play them.

The close range goals kept coming, with Declan Keilty sent on for the second half and mysteriously used as a ruckman in a contest where the other bloke beat him all ends up at a forward pocket bounce and turned around to kick the easiest of goals. To his credit Keilty - just as I was searching for a paper bag to breathe into - went into the middle and delivered a perfect centre bounce tap. He went on to spend most of the second half rucking. To say they didn't like Preuss' performance would be an understatement. For a while I thought he'd gone off at half time, before he cropped up for this Greco Roman manouevre:




He was later seen sitting on a green Bunnings plastic chair looking like he was about to go on an armed rampage. In Shepparton who would notice?

We were officially into the death spiral when they first missed an absolute sitter from right in front, then crumbed another at close range to extend the margin to 14. At this stage I considered ringing my boss and thanking him for preventing me from driving three hours to stand in 36 degree heat and watch this. Our transition into the forward line had gone from effortless to horrible, and Richmond players were forming an orderly line and waiting for the ball to be kicked to them.

It took Dylan Grimes - who had turned up dressed like Rey Misterio Jr due to a facial injury - throwing a ridiculous handball across the face of goal to gift Maynard a tap-in for our first of the term. A second unexpectedly followed before the end when Weideman was on the end of the first 'out the back' goal for the season to cut the margin a more manageable 18. Then it became a less manageable 24 when they ran into another open goal with 41 seconds to play? In a tribute to great DemonTime disasters of the past we nearly let another one in with two seconds to play.

We were rooted, time to get as much out of the last quarter as possible and wave the cavalcade of missing players back in. To say I didn't expect a blockbusting comeback would be an understatement, and even less so when Richmond kicked a goal a minute in via having about 11 players standing free around goal. It looked like we'd given up, and so had Fox Sports, who acknowledged that it was practically a VFL game by switching to a count up clock. Soon that disappeared, came back showing 88:88 and went away again, only recovering to the traditional countdown method in the last few minutes. Some people think there should always be a count up clock, but when I die during a close finish let it be on your heads.

What looked like their sealer was instantly cancelled out via the unusual combination of ruck sensation Keilty's tap, and Corey Wagner's goal. This was an appropriate Kingsley-esque response to Maverick Weller going for a pre-season nomination at the other end.

As the sting went out of the game and everyone began to realise they only had a six day break until their next game, we got a couple in a row to nudge closer. McDonald got a goal from a downfield free to keep his spirits up after a day of persecution at the hands of Richmond's defence, then JFK banged through a set shot to bring it back to 18. When Oliver won a free, tried to play on, fell over, was tackled and somehow got a 50 everything was going our way again. Doubly so when the same umpire who'd been dudded into giving the first one tacked on a second and guaranteed the goal.

When Anal-Bullet cut the margin to seven and Tom Sparrow kicked a point I was left scrambling for the record books to see if we've ever had a draw in a pre-season game. Early indications suggest no, but next time I'm at a loose end I'll be doing a full investigation to confirm (Update - 1934 vs Sandhurst). Not relevant anyway, because even as I found myself nervously chewing fingernail at our last chance of sharing the zero points, Richmond rebounded the other way and sealed it.

Life goes on. I'd say bring me the shit teams, but we're no longer at a stage where we can feel comfortable just to give good teams a scare. Let's chalk it up to an afternoon of lessons learnt for lesser lights, celebrate that nobody died of heatstroke and be thankful that they didn't find the team bus up on bricks.

Paul Prymke Plate for Pre-Season Performance
5 - Clayton Oliver
4 - Angus Brayshaw
3 - Christian Salem
2 - Christian Petracca
1 - James Harmes

Apologies to Fritsch, JKH, Weideman and Keilty for his surprise second half rucking cameo.

Leaderboard
All to play for with pre-season game to go. Here I was thinking that the extra game would help clear out the leaderboard but instead if none of the top four poll we're a chance of the biggest tie in Demonblog history. We're getting extra plates shipped from the Selangor Pewter factory just in case.

5 - Angus Brayshaw, Max Gawn, Clayton Oliver, Christian Salem
4 - James Harmes, Braydon Preuss
2 - Christian Petracca

Media Watch
If I'm not going to be able to do Crowd Watch every week, then this will have to do as an alternative. With your hosts, Stoned Huddo and Normal State Dwayne.

It was one of the least baffling appearances by Dermott Brereton in recent years, obviously warming up to a big season of knowing what he's talking about but not being able to explain it in under 4000 words (which is sort of like this blog, except I don't know what I'm talking about). But what's his connection to Richmond's Jack Ross? He talked about him like he'd just bought stocks and was trying to run a Wolf of Wall Street style pump and dump scam.

The man who once violently defended the honour of Craig Nettlebeck's dog has form for working personal causes into his media work. This includes one of the most insane 10 minutes of radio ever when some private schoolkid was accused of racism and Derm hijacked a segment that had absolutely nothing to do with schoolboy footy to put over what a great the kid the accused was and all but publicly say the accuser was lying. For all I knew (or cared) he might have been spot on, but it was a shameless use of valuable airtime (well, SEN airtime anyway) to advance a personal cause. Insane actions by media personalities may be all that gets me through this season so bring it on.

Coming This Week
1) An AFLW match review

2) The latest arriving season preview of all time. At least it will take into account the 10 week recovery period for Mitch Hannan after some mystery surgery that nobody knew about and Keilty now being a ruck medal contender.

Next Week
Brisbane at Casey next Saturday afternoon. Fat chance I'm going all that way but will be watching live on TV. Send your Crowd Watch comments to the usual address. I rate the Lions to be at least mid-table this year, but without knowing how many of our absent players are going to come back I still think we should win comfortably. It will be the debut of Steven May, which together with horrific memories of playing for the Scorpions might send Stefan Martin running straight back out the door towards Cranbourne.

Final Thoughts
Conceding 113 was not welcome, but we lost that with our second string defence but kicked 101 against a premiership lineup who held our spearhead quiet. Losing is rubbish, and it didn't feel we should have got so close but I'll take it.

Monday, 25 February 2019

The Cardiac Club

On paper the world's greatest expansion team should have beaten us easily like they have everyone else so far, but I held some hope based on a) the ease of the Brisbane win last week and perhaps more hopefully b) Northern Tasmania not coping with warm conditions after barely ever playing on the mainland of Australia. For the second time this season we faced an interstate team at a warm, windy Casey Fields and fell agonisingly short of victory. This may be a familiar feeling to you, we've now lost seven games in three years and five of those have been by less than a goal.

In trying to slay what has been built up as an unbeatable machine I'd like to have got off to a hot start, and indeed like most weeks we attacked early for no reward. You did get the feeling we'd have scored against a lesser team, but North were set up well. Even when excitement machine Aleisha Newman grabbed a ball of the pack and had a quick shot around the corner there was a 'goalkeeper' in the square to stop it.

The early difference was with the quality of set shots by the forwards. Special K spokeswoman Mo Hope goalled from a free (this becomes quite the trend) with a 40 metre set shot, while down the other end we had a player standing roughly the same distance out with a light breeze in her face and she had to try a short pass that came to nothing. After our record setting marks inside 50 tally last week it was back to struggling to create set shot opportunities, and again most of the marks came too far out for anyone to do anything with them.

With marks inside 30 metres absent it fell to Cat Phillips to create her own opportunity by first smothering, then converting on the run for her first goal since the 2017 Freo avalanche. Despite this, and keeping them without another goal for the rest of the quarter, North always looked far more likely to score while we were back to making forward movements seem overly complicated. Getting away with a 6-7 quarter time deficit was welcome but didn't feel sustainable.

North looked more likely to score, while we reverted to our good opposition stance of making forward movements look overly complicated. Got away with a 6-7 quarter time deficit, but it didn't look sustainable. There wasn't much in the way of loose footy inside 50, Zanker did a great job as a second ruck but couldn't get the ball in her hand forward. Neither did Cunningham at first, though she came good later in both kicking goals and punching opponents in the guts.

The second quarter started with Lauren Pearce's latest Max Gawn (or if you prefer, the next big thing Braydon Preuss) impersonation in the middle, but we lost the centre clearance and the female Kent Kingsley, Mo Hope inadvertently set up a goal with an ambitious shot that fell short into the arms of a giraffe like forward thrilling wearing #60. She got two in a row, and when we blew a golden chance at a goal by stuffing up a snap from the top of the square I gave up all hope and started to work on the Ms. Bradbury Plan.

Googling AFLW ladder brought up a page that implied the conference system had been abolished,

But sadly no, sanity has not prevailed and the real thing was elsewhere, confirming that we're still going to miss out with a record that would probably win Group B.

Also from the AFLW website, the birth of children described in terms of how exciting it will be for supporters. Presumably Daisy and Mr Daisy are very happy with this development as well.

I was already piecing the plan together when Cunningham turned up to take a couple of inside 50 grabs and kick a goal that cut the gap to five. She celebrated with a casual jab to an opponent on the ground that the match review panel/individual will definitely go her for out of spite at their suspension from last week being overturned.

That glory didn't last for long, a series of bullshit frees marched North to the square for their reply. A margin of 10 at half time wasn't insurmountable if we got a run on, but you felt (rightly as it turned out) they had enough to keep us at bay - including one defender who was getting in the way of everything we tried. Our control of the ball was good until it got to the half-forward line, then it was all out guesswork and hoping for the best.

We finally had to make a goal of nothing, with Newman on the end of some silky ball movement to fly through the middle of the ground and roll it through an unguarded square. Next thing you knew Tyla Hanks kicked one off the outside of her boot, we were in front, and my half time investigation of the fixture to see how we might fall into second place seemed premature. Then straight out of the middle Mo Kingsley wound up with another set shot, now has more than 25% of her career AFLW goals against us and the advantage was lost.

The last quarter was watched with a significantly high degree of difficulty, on a moving train full of nuffies going to an Eminem concert. I avoided being held up for my phone by a man in a yellow tracksuit long enough to see us half stuff up and half be rorted by a serious of mystifying decisions. It started well enough with Newman's second goal, but we failed to put them away.

After 3.5 quarters of thumping each other both teams were flagging when Paxman gave away an unnecessary 50 with the ball in our forward line, and next thing it was down the other end with #60 getting one of the all time great BULLSHIT in the back frees for the go ahead goal. The only explanation I have is that something happened off the ball but the callers didn't notice because Kate Sheahan was talking the greatest degree of special comments bollocks since Malcolm Blight and Leigh Montagna was constantly correcting himself from saying "ruckman" like he was going to be frogmarched from the stadium for lacking gender awareness. If his peripheral involvement in one of the most prominent footy sex scandals of the century isn't enough to DQ him from calling women's games I don't think grappling with preferred terminology is going to get him the sack.

The goal left us with three minutes to find a response, which was about as likely as the Reverend Fred Nile leading the Mardi Gras. We were partially responsible for our doom, but not helped by a series of bullshit free kicks in North's half of the ground. Ironically our chance at going forward was kept alive despite the ball with ball in hand stepping so far over the boundary line that she was nearly at Cranbourne Station.

It came to nothing, we lost, and it's not only all or nothing for our remaining three games but we're into the familiar role of having to hope for other teams to fall over in front of us. Strange as it may seem, before this year we'd actually won more games by less than a goal than we'd lost.

2019 Daisy Pearce Medal
Despite almost beating the top team it was a pretty flat performance for voting purposes. For instance it was nowhere near Paxman's best game but still hard to leave her out of the top two because of a lack of other convincing options. Your views may vary, start your own blog.

5 - Lily Mithen
4 - Karen Paxman
3 - Lauren Pearce
2 - Tegan Cunningham
1 - Aleisha Newman

Leaderboard
The plot thickens at the top, as Pearce puts some space in front of the surprisingly flat O'Dea but concedes one off her lead on Paxman.

17 - Lauren Pearce
13 - Karen Paxman
9 - Elise O'Dea
7 - Lily Mithen
4 - Harriet Cordner, Aleisha Newman

2 - Tegan Cunningham, Tyla Hanks, Eden Zanker

Ms. Bradbury Plan
Our last three games are GWS (win), Bulldogs (win?) and Adelaide (win??), and any losses will consign this plan straight to the tip but assuming we keep our destiny at least partially in our own hands by winning we want:

North to win every week and finish top unbeaten, starting with Adelaide next week. If the Crows win then shut the gate. Would be nice - but unlikely - for Adelaide to lose against GWS as well.

Equally unlikely is the Bulldogs beating Freo next week. If they do that then lose to us they're probably out of the race anyway, but losing to Carlton in the final round would make sure they were dead and buried. If the Dockers win against Footscray then they must lose to both Geelong and North. The latter I can see, but they would start favourites against Geelong.

As long as North beat the Crows I can see it coming down to the last game again. And we all know what's going to happen there...

Crowd Watch
I know they're in Cranbourne, but I'm sure a kid in the background of that kick was drinking Woodstock. Turns out not far from the truth:
Next Week
GWS should be nothing more than a speed bump, but I'm still not over that shambles of a defeat in the first season when they were 100% no good. Now they're at least competitive so anything could happen. Should win, must win.

Final thoughts
It's becoming increasingly obvious that this team is destined to fall heartbreakingly short at every opportunity, until the point where there's a full compliment of 18 teams in the league and winning a flag becomes as difficult as the men's competition. At least North's success means they'll neuter the four 2020 expansion sides to make sure they're not too good too soon, but the premiership window is still shrinking. Time to turn to any sort of unhanded and potentially illegal tactic short of injecting the players with Mexican greyhound racing drugs.

Saturday, 23 February 2019

One win down, 27 to go.


Welcome to our 15th year of covering senior men's Australian Rules football as played by - or in some years around - the Melbourne Football Club. When this blog started Olympic Park was still being used for school athletics carnivals, now it's a public access venue where you can let your dog drop a steamer in the goalsquare and play largely tension free pre-season scratch matches. Year 15 begins like Year 1, with a win in a throwaway low profile match.

In the club's much anticipated return to games in the Olympic Park precinct for the first time since 1932 we won and nobody dislocated their spine, so while like bowling a strike in the first frame I can't confirm it's a pointer to future success I'll take the zero points and run.

When the club played its first game at the fancifully named Motordrome in '32 there was an early outbreak of matchday experience when they had commentators calling the game over loudspeakers. At least for a few minutes until fans and players alike complained and it was stopped. Fittingly in our return to the same piece of land nearly 77 years later somebody pulled the plug on this coverage too. This time inadvertently:

At first I felt like a traitor for not going, but the shenanigans of the broadcast made it all worthwhile. The kicked cable was just the main event of a cavalcade of technical mishaps that elevated the viewing experience beyond just live streaming of a scratch match and into something to be fondly remembered. Footy wasn't bad either. Last time I went to this ground was for a corporate AFL 9s tournament where I nearly kicked through the wrong posts running into an open goal and was comprehensively battered by a team of Collingwood assistant coaches/hangers on where Simon Prestigiacomo of all people persecuted us at full forward with about nine goals.

We should have known something exciting was on the way when shortly before the coverage started you heard somebody on a live mic say "this happens every time". The 'this' they were referring to obviously wasn't all the microphones working, because we then got about five minutes of pre-match chat with Nathan Jones where you couldn't hear a word he was saying. Eventually somebody off-camera let them know, so he removed his headset and talked into a handheld microphone that didn't work either. After 15 awkward minutes the co-host roped in from the Herald Sun was ejected so Jones could use his microphone. He got to talk for about 30 seconds before the game started and he was moved on.

The first bounce was a case of starting as you mean to go on, with the umpires pinging Gawn for allegedly jumping into his opponent at the bounce. Looked like a regulation contest to me, but the Administrative Free League is nothing without baffling decisions that even the players involved don't understand. To cap off a great first two minutes for anti-umpire sentiment, Collingwood's first goal came from another randomly plucked free.

This is where the lights went out on Olympic Boulevard. Jones was called back on mic to give his thoughts, and the effort taken to find him a working microphone caused the feed to shut down. As far as major sponsors went it was OUT: Zurich, IN: Baghdad. I was hoping that the umpire had been standing in the middle waiting for the 'all clear' light from the host broadcaster the whole time. Alas no, and we recovered vision after about 10 minutes just after American History X lookalike Braydon Preuss had kicked his first and was running around throwing high fives to all and sundry.

The power was back, but the strain on the commentary team had taken its toll and they were unheard for a few minutes, replaced by the pleasant background noise of the crowd, before somebody said "we'll start calling again" and all the audio dropped out. At least this time the pictures survived, allowing us to salivate over a towering Weideman mark in the square for a second goal that tied it at 13.

Watching in silence was better than not watching at all, or with Dwayne involved, but it was still unnerving. If they'd switched to black and white - and by this stage you couldn't rule anything out - it would have looked like one of those unearthed films of the 1912 Grand Final discovered under somebody's floorboards. Even on an enforced mute you knew it was pre-season because a) a player was stretching out during the first quarter, b) the Man with a Van truck stopped in traffic directly behind the play, and c) there was a one-two goalkicking punch of Billy Stretch and Jay Kennedy-Harris that put us two goals up at quarter time. At which point the feed spiralled into death again and somebody tried to reboot the computer.

From the half a quarter I could see our ball movement looked good, and when it comes to pre-season games you assume anything that works will also go well in the real stuff while anything that goes wrong is instantly dismissed as meaningless.

After scaring the bejesus out of anyone listening on headphones with the sound of a plane nearly plowing into the ground, the second quarter resumed with pictures, crowd noise from people standing next to the commentary area, somebody saying a loud and clear "TESTING MIC THREE!" then shitloads of static like mic three had been dropped into a bucket of water. Forget going to see the game live, I was having 300% more fun with the non-stop thrill ride of waiting to see what would happen to the live stream next. Amidst this carnage they were so moved by a Joel Smith screamer that a replay ran, risking putting the coverage off the air for good.

Smith's massive grab was welcome, but not as much as Preuss dismissing his opponent at a forward 50 ball up with the greatest of ease and turning to snap a goal. There were plenty of times last year where we didn't take advantage of stoppages inside 50 due to McSizzle battling manfully to break even so this could be a game (CLICHE) changer. With no Brodie Grundy the opposition ruckman could have been from the Leeward Islands for all I know, but our ruck combination looked hotter than the sun.

Preuss' goal inspired the commentary to return again, with one bloke presumably using mic three who could be heard properly, and another who briefly sounded like he was on the phone from the bottom of a tin mine in Chad, then dropped out entirely again.

We dominated on the scoreboard in the second quarter, but the Pies certainly had their chances. They just kicked for goal like a dose of leprosy had run through the squad until sneaking a cheap one right at the end. Being let off the hook occasionally didn't cause me too much heartache, add Lever and May to the defence, Sizzle and Milkshake to the forwards and Oliver/Viney into the midfield and start counting dollars.

If I've got anything to be concerned about - other than a shithouse early draw - it's that our forward line is too tall. They looked really good here but crumb was in short supply. Garlett didn't do much until the last quarter so Melksham, Petracca and the midfield will have to chip in. The goal will have to be to exploit this 6-6-6 positioning nonsense to get quick kicks from the middle straight to the marking talls and never let the ball hit the ground. Corey Wagner of all people stuffed one through from a goalmouth scramble late in the quarter but I'm not pinning my hopes on that happening every week.

After walking out of the room for a second I returned to hear what sounded like Robert Walls being interviewed. Turned out to be Gary Pert, exercising the CEO's option to a working mic. Later they had Josh Mahoney on, and for all the weird stuff that was going on I appreciated their light entertainment presentation rather than trying to call every bit of the action. Ok in the pre-season, likely to provoke murder if Basil Zempilas returns to do it from Round 1.

It was a solid first half, and the third started flawlessly via quick ball movements setting up Tim Smith to run onto a loose ball in the square and boot it through. The Collingwood defender was convinced it had already crossed the line, but stiff shit if you're hoping for a goal review in a practice match. If that was questionable then the second free of the quarter was even worse, with Weid getting a soft as butter free that he missed from close range.

If the latest set of off-season rule changes were supposed to encourage scoring then we might be on the end of another few before Round 1. Stand by for a couple of high scoring games in the first few weeks that cause spectacle-chasing journos to declare the game is BACK (when it was never went anywhere in the first place), before coaches twig and put the screws on, leaving the same reporters banging the door down to try and get the rules changed to create 150-149 thrillers.

The scoring might not have gone off the charts, but we still did our bit for entertainment. It took 15 minutes for the second goal of the quarter, but it came via a moment of rare beauty. Petracca delivered a lightning handball off the deck, which Harmes expertly collected and finished without breaking stride. That is the sort of stuff that will make 30 mystery free kicks and 50s for going north/south instead of east/west worthwhile.

We'd seen enough in the first three quarters that flubbing a 25 point three quarter time lead wouldn't matter that much, but I still instinctively tensed up when they got the first goal of the final term. The gene that always has me on high alert for a shambles is going to take a generation to be evolved out of the species. Fortunately Garlett quickly bobbed up for almost the first time all day to pluck the ball off a marking contest and roll through an open goal to calm whatever misplaced nerves I had.

Garbage trucks were seen going down Punt Road midway through the quarter as junk time was declared. Nobody wanted to be the player to make all the fears about AFLX injuries look silly by necking themselves in a real game on the same day. Almost everyone complied, except the real nutters like Aaron vandenBerg who only have one setting. I clambered onto the vandWagon for 2019 when he split a Pies player in two with a ball-tearer of a tackle that directly led to Anal-Bullet drilling the sealer. Midfield vandenBerg is best vandenBerg, and this was a classic mismatch of a player who was happy to get to the siren unscathed meeting somebody who is genetically predisposed to thumping people.

Nothing is certain in this competition, but it was as good a hitout as you were going to get against a 75% strength opposition who were also missing a swathe of their best players. I'm nowhere near as convinced as most that these are two automatically top four teams, but I can see us sticking around the same spot as them for the next few years. Now that we've beaten them in women's football and bruise free football (with apologies to AVB) time to get back to doing it in the real stuff.

Paul Prymke Plate for Pre-season performance
Votes are always subjective, more so when you don't see half the first quarter. I feel the integrity of the Plate (former winners include Lumumba, Watts, Howe and Hogan) is in question if I award, so I just went by the bests on the club website. This was risky considering the same article suggested Tim Smith was battling Spargo and Garlett for a small forward position (pardon?) but reasonably well aligned to my views.

5 - Max Gawn
4 - Braydon Preuss
3 - James Harmes
2 - Christian Salem
1 - Angus Brayshaw

I also liked Hore, who would have walked into our Round 1 back when our defence was solid as Iraq but will now need to wait until the other defenders suffer their inevitable injuries.

Banner Watch
The Demon Army are good, but even I don't expect them to do something for a half-arsed match. Instead, here's a classic of the genre:
Tonight
I managed to retain some of my principles by refusing to participate in AFLX, but congratulations to Bayley Fritsch for lifting his second premiership and instantly becoming the greatest player in the history of the sport. Thanks to the millions of international viewers foaming at the mouth to get involved he'll never have to buy a drink in Shanghai again

Sunday 
AFLW coverage from Casey. I'll be reviewing off the TV, so if you want to have a bash at guest reporting (either live or from the not-Cranbourne security of your couch) please get in touch via the usual channels. In case you missed it, but mostly because I really like the headline, here's the post from last week.

Next Week
Richmond at Shepparton, in a fixture that in past years I'd have dropped everything to attend. Now because I'm dealing with a midlife crisis I'll be going off the grid while at work and watching late Sunday night. Here's to a respectable performance against Richmond providing us further signs of a safe, top eight at least life.

Final Thoughts
I don't really think we're going to win the flag (though a lot of that is self-preservation so I don't get sad if it goes wrong), but what I took out of this is that we're not going to be shit. In many years that was all that we could ask for in the first game of the season, now let us get to the task of piledriving everybody in sight.