Pages

▼

Sunday, 8 November 2026

Oh my hat

I've got nothing but appreciation for Mick Stinear's time as our coach, but scientists at the Demonblog Institute have confirmed that waiting all year for the first awkward meeting in a final, then blowing the biggest lead in AFLW history, and losing thanks to a missed sitter is PISS FUNNY. May he enjoy good times at Geelong, preferably finishing second behind us every year, but unless the legacy of the Princes Park Miracle is ruined by them coming back to beat us in the Grand Final, the key memory of Stinear vs Melbourne Pt. 1 will always be the tremendous cock-up of losing from 28 points in front in the third quarter.

If you move the game to a different timeslot it doesn't play out in the same way (take note: people who moan about 25/09/21 not happening in Victoria, as if we'd definitely still have finished the game with a 100-7 to run), but this was a prime time finish with more storylines than a season of Home and Away. Instead, it played the opening act of a double header at 1.05pm. If you're also a bozo who hasn't  yet cancelled Kayo for the summer, coverage started what was meant to be five minutes before the bounce.  Which hardly screamed 'frenzied finals atmosphere'. I don't know why Foxtel wasted their time putting pre-match studio shows on for ordinary games earlier in the season, but I guess their $3.50 AFLW budget has been exhausted, and we didn't even get that.

You'd have been lucky to know this was on if not specifically looking for it. In Kayo's 'Live and Upcoming' scroller, it came after cricket (fair enough), V8 Supercars (ok), college American Football (?), Padel (!?) and the Australian Volleyball Superleague (sure, why not). For what these bastards charge, the system should know that someone who pretty much only ever watches AFL/W would prefer a final to the Canberra Heat vs Adelaide Storm volleyball blockbuster. 

There's always the option of watching Channel 7, if you want every goal to be followed by Mon Conti saying "right stitch up" as if she's being held at gunpoint by militants. But if you also made the mistake of trying to access the game at exactly 1pm and had to use every bit of willpower available to scroll the 'tennis in a plastic box' intensity of Padel, the first bounce was delayed by nearby lightning. Last week the game carried on after the lightning allegedly got within 'stop the game' range, so I don't know what the difference was here. It played havoc with the limited time I had to watch live, but best not risk everyone being flambeéd for my convenience.

Even without the ex-coach shenanigans, this game had as much box office potential as possible in front of a crowd of 4743. Geelong, unable to play at home due to people jumping bikes over large mounds of dirt (notably absent from the list of fringe sports available on Kayo), arrived with the best attacking record in AFLW history, while we're the ultimate all-rounders. Not the best in any category, none of the players ever win major awards, but it all comes together in a 'near enough to the top in every aspect' to make us dangerous opposition for anybody except North after the first quarter.

For the first 2.5 quarters we were outplayed, but also had all sorts of bad luck. Like Hore standing on her own inside 50 early in the first quarter, only for the ball to develop a sense of humour instead of sitting up perfectly for her to turn around and snap. Due to being great, the captain was still able to regather for another shot, but the moment had passed. Geelong's kick-in barely made it across the 50 before it was back with Harris for a set shot. She's done plenty of good things this year, but kicking accuracy is not amongst them. The trend continued with a big helicoptering slopball that went OOF in the pocket.

All the attack was to the left of screen, but we've seen multiple games this year where the opposition failed to take advantage of early chances, and it wound up costing them dearly. Which nearly happened here, but after a player ran the half marathon on her way inside 50 without bouncing, they botched the finale, it remained goalless, and the game went into a few minutes of teams going up and down the ground for no reward. As far as finals go, the first W outing didn't exactly hit the heights of the last two games in the M season.

Finally, it looked like things were going our way when Bannan marked 20 metres out directly in front. Which was nice. Then hit the post, which wasn't. At the time this looked like a horribly blown opportunity, but was revealed as part of long-term Usual Suspects-style storytelling in the final minute. And after we'd done all that attack for just three behinds and cleared multiple chances down the other end, the opposition got lucky c/o a defender hopefully hoofing the ball from distance, which got the perfect bounce to skip through past a looming Lauren Pearce. Bah.

One chance of a response died when Horisk got a valuable learning experience about what not to do when running into an open goal on a slight angle. Another disappeared at the end of the quarter when the ball once more refused to go where we needed it to. It wasn't our most inspiring start, but we've started with 0.0 and won before, so no need to quaff poison yet. But you may have thought about mixing your Erin Patterson Mushroom Surprise milkshake when McNamara and Mahony had a "you first, no you first" moment over running onto a loose ball inside 50 early in the second term. This led to the ball going *BOING* down the other end, where ex-Melburnian Jacqueline Parry ran into an open goal. Which was 2x better than her last season with us, which generated just three behinds from eight games. 

There was now bright sunshine (for those not kicking to the Carlton Wall End), but we were playing like a team still waiting to be incinerated by lightning at any moment. After doing well to keep the scoring juggernaut to one fluky goal in the first half, the old floodgates were starting to heave under pressure, and I was ready to get morbidly depressed as a kick headed for a forward standing in miles of space. That was, until Gillard turned up at the last minute with one of her famous Inspector Gadget spoils. This led to the ball arriving at a spot in front of our goal where any mark would've likely led to a goal (having said that, based on some of the other set shots...), before landing in the middle of about four Melbourne players. 

Meanwhile, down the other end Geelong kicked one from 40 metres out, and you got the feeling that things were about to go tits up. But a team three goals to zilch up at Princes Park, what could possibly go wrong? Something had to, because our performance until the epic comeback was about as much fun as doing your taxes while being dipped into an erupting volcano. Like when they got another goal via plucked from the arse crumb not long after we'd been rorted out of a free on the wing. 

Things were going so badly that we spectacularly violated the 6-6-6 rule, with Fitzsimon having to run back to defence from the other end of the ground to comply. Unlike Matthew Richardson whinging about the warning every time it happens, I've got no problem with giving teams one free administrative error before they're penalised, but the payoff should be that you don't get to choose who goes where. The nearest player to the backline has to move there, the player incorrectly roaming the forward 50 has to stand 1cm inside the midfield zone, and stiff shit if the opposition takes advantage.

You may have considered necking a suspiciously bubbling concoction when Bannan dropped a mark right in front of goal, then Hanks got buried in a savage tackle. But enter the returning McNamara, fresh from a few weeks drinking through a straw to breathe life into a game that looked as if it would be dead by half-time. This had to survive the AFL's world leading 'Score Assist' technology, which didn't even have the same goal line vision as Unley bloody Oval. 

After that excitement, we nearly gave the goal straight back after a Geelong forward made light contact in the back seem like she'd been hit by a cannonball. The kick missed, and our hopes of avoiding the peril of a potential straight sets finish remained alive. That's until Parry marked with a broken time clock showing 1.56 instead of the actual 0.00, the person pushing the siren button held it down for so long that they were either a) really keen to let you know it was supposed to be half time, or; b) had died face first on the console. A difficult kick became a certainty when she got a 50 for somebody slightly breaching the protected zone. 

I understand if the player runs across the mark during the run-up, but isn't the protected zone supposed to stop interference when quick play ons? Which you can't do when kicking a set shot after the siren. So what does it matter if somebody briefly wanders into the same postcode? You don't want to encourage players to hang around within earshot of the kicking, yelling slurs to put them off, but common sense says the accidental wander past is hardly worth conceding a goal. 

Conceding in those circumstances said everything you needed to know about our first half. But, as coach Stinear was no doubt aware, the last Melbourne/Geelong final involved a massive thwarted comeback. So, for all the relevance that game had three seasons later, YOU NEVER KNEW (*insert ominous foreshadowing music* - soundtrack editor). But you did know (and turned out to be wrong), when the ball got right in front of our goal seconds into the quarter for no score, then Taylor injured an ankle when the ever-present Parry rolled her up like a wrestling pinfall. 

This led to a goal from O'Hehir of all people, but quicker than you could do the deviant Sid James O'Hehhehehehehehir laugh, they cancelled it out. When another came straight after, I'd had just about enough of footy for the 2026 calendar year. Then Harris got hurt too, and I wondered if the volleyball was still on. But never mind, because here's Heath-Barker for a goal that Geelong players couldn't have been more adamant they'd touched without submitting a statutory declaration. This was going to test the score review system... which didn't even get used... What in god's name is going on with this process? 

Our response to this slice of luck was... conceding pretty much from the centre bounce. Then, our incredibly shit run with the bounce continued with Hore about to swoop on a loose ball inside 50, only for it to make a wacky momentum-killing change of direction. BUT, slender hope was pumped into our chances of doing something silly when Hanks got a goal from the kick in. Then, the ball finally worked to Hore's advantage, and the margin was back to 13. 

It kept things interesting, but surely to god we weren't going to overcome a 28 point gap and the opposition's dominance to win. I was happy just to be involved in the last quarter, but the best outcome I could imagine was a brave defeat. Until Bannan chucked one through in the opening seconds, leaving plenty of time for Geelong to shit their shorts under pressure. They'd been so good for most of the game, but went missing when it counted. It still required us to kick two goals (or one goal + numerous behinds) to overrun them, which was where I thought we'd go wrong and end up doing the old "Maybe don't go [number] of points behind before turning up" whinge.

This goal came just at the right time to stop me going into a one-hour delay, assuming all the time that we'd lost. Instead, I was reduced to watching on a phone, while sitting in my car right outside Arden Street. Then, after 10 minutes of back-and-forth knife-edge drama, Bannan's second set shot was about 99.9% better than the first and left us a point down. Sure, the kick was paid a mark after travelling what looked like about nine metres, but who are we to question the AFLW umpires when they've got such a quality track record of getting decisions right.

I still refused to believe Geelong wouldn't kick another goal, even though they'd dropped anchor and stopped dead 30 minutes earlier. The way it was going, we may have run over the top if it went to extra time (and hopefully thrown off the schedule of the later game at Princes Park), and I was prepared to take that route if necessary. Then enter Paxy, for the ironic 'sinking of ex-coach' crumb. The chance came via a quick shot by Wotherspoon - who had as good a game as any forward without registering a score - which fell short. Bannan's marking contest propelled the ball into Paxman's path, surprisingly didn't bounce off in an unhelpful direction, and set up the snap to put us ahead with 2.30 left. Extra comedy value for a foundation player with a career record of a goal every three games sinking the only AFLW coach played under until this year.

I reacted by vigorously slapping my leg in celebration, which probably looked a bit suss to any onlookers, but once the joy was over I went back to fretting. After all, what's a five point lead if not a one point loss waiting to happen? So when the ball went inside Geelong's forward 50, I thought "here we go". Especially when the umpire signalled for high contact free, and we had to wait and see what direction he'd point in before knowing what was going on. Why do umpires gesture the 'wrong' way for frees? Is it supposed to indicate who the free is against, rather than who it's for, as if we couldn't work that out. And do we still need the extravagant gestures for free kick reasons? Just whistle, point, and get on with things. It's not 1945, we don't need dramatic deep squats and the 'no more bets' gesture to indicate holding the ball. These changes could save up to four seconds per game, and I'll wait patiently for my invitation to join the AFL Competition Committee.

This left Geelong still needing nothing less than a goal to win, and wouldn't you bloody know it, a hack kick from a pack landed perfectly to the advantage of a player 20 metres out, directly in front. It didn't travel much further than the one they paid to Bannan, but can't complain after getting away with one at our end. Here endeth, so it seems, the brave Melbourne revival. By the time she'd run 40 seconds off the clock, there wasn't enough time to get any score out of the middle without the most express centre break in AFLW history. 

But, while the ads tell us you shouldn't trust anyone but Terri Scheer for landlord insurance, don't rely on her sister Chloe for clutch goalkicking. After landing one from distance + angle earlier, she horribly shanked this with perhaps the worst kick to win a game since Sticks Kernahan went OOF while only needing a point. Talk about a stroke of luck. Certainly made up for all the bad bounces earlier. There was all sorts of "we must think about the feelings of the player who missed" good vibes shit afterwards, but there's no denying it was a massive botch job. And for that, we say thank you very much.

This left us with 10 seconds to navigate the kick-in and survive for a miraculous victory. To lose after all that with a failed short pass or kick-in straight over the line may have put me away. Fortunately, the 'hoof it as far away from goal as possible' method helped run down the clock, and somehow we'd completed the biggest heist in league history.

If it was the world's most tedious niche movie, I'd have rolled the car window down, looked towards Arden Street from the left-side window of my car and dramatically said, "You're next!" But this first required them to lose to Carlton, which was never going to happen, would have been an incredibly weird thing to do, and you can't open your window when the car is turned off. Any onlookers would've already thought I was nuts after reacting to the Paxman goal, so no need to risk the police getting involved with a Prelim on the horizon. The only charges I want to be facing in November are charges to my card for Grand Final tickets. 

2026 Daisy Pearce Medal votes
5 - Olivia Purcell
4 - Tahlia Gillard
3 - Tyla Hanks
2 - Ryleigh Wotherspoon
1 - Georgia Campbell

Apologies to Allen, Bannan, Harris, Heath-Barker, Lampard, and McNamara.

Leaderboard
The gap at the top narrows slightly, but thanks to Pegleg Pam from Geelong, only 10 votes remain, leaving Purcell with a mountain to climb for the heartwarming double-knee explosion-to-glory redemption story. How about Hanks wins this, Liv gets BOG in a Grand Final win, and everyone goes home happy? 

Speaking of GF Best on Ground awards, Tahlia Gillard may still be waiting for the AFL to correct their error and present her the 2022 (Spring) medal, but she's right back in the mix to win our equally prestigious Defender of the Year. In 20+ years I've never manipulated the outcome of a vote yet, so keep that in mind in the event of a fitting draw with Chaplin.

And in the Rookie of the Year, Allen can still be caught, but it would require something massively insane to happen.

44 - Tyla Hanks
--- Needs two finals ---
37 - Olivia Purcell
--- Back for another go in 2027 ---
20 - Maeve Chaplin (JOINT LEADER: Defender of the Year), Tahlia Gillard (JOINT LEADER: Defender of the Year)
14 - Ryleigh Wotherspoon
12 - Kate Hore
9 - Jordyn Allen (PROVISIONAL WINNER: Rising Star Award), Mia Austin
7 - Tayla Harris, Eliza McNamara
6 - Megan Fitzsimon
4 - Georgia Campbell (LEADER: Ruck of the Year)
3 - Alyssa Bannan 
1 - Shelley Heath-Barker, Aoife Horisk, Sarah Lampard

Goal of the Week
Impossible to go past the Paxman snap, and as I've got the spirit of Deesus flowing through me at the moment, I'm upgrading it to the season leader.

Next week +1
It's Hawthorn OR Carlton, both beaten this year with varying degrees of difficulty, but each capable of rumbling us on their day. There's a new frontier for humiliation if we allow the Hawks to make a Grand Final from 8th, so probably safer if Carlton win and we just take it from there. Who knows how many bullshit mid-week injuries we've got coming to us before then.

Final thoughts
It wasn't a performance that suggested we're about to become the New North, but delivered what we needed (eventually), when we needed it. What more could you ask for?

Wednesday, 4 November 2026

Unley Fans

As we readied ourselves for a placeholder game on the way to finals, the 'Dead Rubber' alarm went off like radiation detectors at Chernobyl when it was conveniently discovered that Olivia Purcell could do with a spot of 'managing' just as results in an earlier game meant this one would have no impact on ladder position. Not sure the AFL care enough about their own competition to make a big deal of it, but imagine the spin required if a 'please explain' landed, enquiring if the late change had anything to do with Gold Coast becoming unable to reel in the massive percentage gap to third. She felt a twinge while leaping to her feet and exclaiming "that's a shame for the plucky young Suns", your honour.

So, it was goodbye to Purcell's guaranteed 30ish disposals a game, as well as earlier withdrawal Georgia Campbell's rapidly improving ruckwork, and the experience of Paxy, who'd been left out as a precaution on Thursday night. No harm done to the feelings of supporters or league integrity because we did as would be expected with a first choice team and won anyway. And zero complaints from me, we've got important action on the horizon that made all our important players going hell for leather on a sodden suburban ground somewhere in the vicinity of Adelaide a low priority. No doubt more stars would've disappeared into the Free Hit Triangle if we had enough fit players to replace them. Would be a bit suspect to call Rent-A-Player just in case Hanks, Harris etc... slid across someone's lost car keys. 

In a week where Adelaide's Grace Kelly became the last remaining AFLW player named after an ill-fated Hollywood starlet, conditions were a fitting tribute to the original version of departing Essendon coach Natalie Wood. It was, to put it mildly, fair pissing down. This set the stage for slog, as the natural competitive instincts of a team with a 9-2 record met mid-table mediocrity-era Adelaide (with no Wildcard Round to make that a desirable status in this competition), attempting to finish the year on a high. What followed was hardly a classic, but we got what was required and nearly escaped without injuries to critical players.

After the recent outbreak of Horisk fever, she nearly got another goal via an early snap. The miss was successfully covered up by Hore going one (five?) better not long after. That goal only lasted as long as Adelaide's first inside 50, which arrived in a backline sans Chaplin, who was working an extra shift in the midfield to make up for Purcell's issues with management. Please note, despite this - and a tweet from the club during the week labelling her 'Midfield Maeve' - the Demonblog awards committee has deemed Chaplin still eligible for the Defender of the Year trophy. Objections may be raised via the Court of Arbitration for Sport in Lausanne... until you're blue in the face, it won't change our ruling.  

That was to be the home side's last goal for a while, and we nearly had the instant-ish reply through Livingstone. She hoofed one from distance that bounced in the square, prompting Pisano to celebrate before realising it may have gone upwards, but was not travelling towards goal fast enough to cross the line untouched. For a moment it seemed to have made it, before the shock return of the multi-angle video review ruled it out. So, at Princes Park, where all the major Victorian finals are played, 'reviews' consist of the umpires getting together for a casual chat, but Unley Oval has cameras in the posts. 

The good news is that AFLW uses a 'vision-based' system, which is better than one relying on audio or clairvoyancy. Now, having seen the mish-mash of random reviews this season, please consider these pre-season comments. 

"AFL Executive General Manager of AFLW, Health and Football Operations Laura Kane said the updated system would deliver a consistent and efficient score review process."

a) How's that going? and;
b) Why is your job title so ludicrous?  

We've got at least two finals to play, both at Princes Park, and if any goal reviews are decided by chit-chat vs actual footage you'll know the AFLEGMoAFLW,HaFO was talking shite.

Once that dispute was sorted out in the manner you'd have expected similar incidents to be handled for the last 11 weeks, the remainder of the opening quarter consisted of players who had "can we just get this over with?" expressions while standing in bucketing rain, bashing away at the Adelaide defence without scoring the all-important (for those of us who don't like losing under any circumstances) second goal. Finally, local resistance was broken in the last minute when resurgent goalkicking option Bannan snuck one through to make our score a slightly more appealing 2.5. 

There was almost another via lightning centre clearance, which I nearly missed while skipping forward to what I thought was going to be quarter time while watching on delay. Wotherspoon missed this one, but compensated with three more and has been our breakout player of the season, so no harm done. 

By now things from our side were a bit "let's just get through this without injuries", and while the effort level remained, you couldn't blame anyone for not risking sliding headfirst into a fence or an opponent's knee. The only remaining novelty value was Channel 7 having a boundary reporter with the same name as our coach, which was a bit like when Amy Parks reported from AAMI Park, but without the preceding 186 point loss and coach sacking. He conducted a weird half-time interview with Tayla Harris which opened with him saying he could hear her "panting", which is not a word you hear used in an AFL context every day. She could barely conceal her contempt for the experience, giving an audio version of that time she used the half-time chat to display the middle finger.

A 19 point half time margin was not entirely secure, but given the conditions near enough to, even with our diminished (both by choice and circumstance) playing stocks. It had looked like the footballing floodgates were about to open when Fitzsimon got the first goal early in the second term, but only one more followed. This still compared favourably to one point for Adelaide, who continued to have a crack in the last game of the season, nothing to lose free hit spirit but couldn't muster up any of the old aura from the days when they were toppling us in a Grand Final.

Just to make sure there was no thought of a surprise comeback, Wotherspoon got a goal on either side of half time, and I'd have died from massive head trauma after falling off my chair in shock if we'd lost from here. Had it been a men's game, I'd have been fretting until deep in the last quarter. It was, however, our last major of the third term, and a fine example of a game where the captains should've been able to shake hands and go off with the margin intact.      

It was unlikely that we'd blow a four goal lead at the last change, and there'd be chuff all ramifications if it happened, but I still carried some background fear about some sort of disaster happening. And it did, but relating to injuries not scoreboard misery. Any sense the Crows had that they were wasting their time sloshing out the season in the suburbs can't have been helped by spending the first five minutes of the last quarter in attack, only for us to go down the other end where Wotherspoon plucked a snap from an obscure angle which took the perfect bounce through without hitting the post. It wouldn't have looked half as good from the other side, but the pokey kick from the right pocket was officially an Appealing Visual Spectacle™.

And... errr.... that was it. The only other interesting thing I've got to point out is that Jacinta Hose's career statistics are currently 1 kick and 11 handballs, so let's see how far she can keep kicks under 10%. As long as Campbell returns, I don't think we'll find out during the finals, but something to think about for next season. 

Otherwise, nothing happened until the final siren... except for the small matter of Kate Hore doing something to her shoulder for god's sake. She hasn't been as critical this year as some in the recent past, but I wouldn't pick many others first for a double chance final extravaganza. But, regardless of the injury list looking worse than the 100 Years' War, we are still neck-deep in the finals, with two chances to wind up losing a Grand Final to North. The new coach inherited an almost universally successful program, and sure we haven't played either of the top two teams yet, but credit to everyone involved for keeping things steady after off-field upheaval, and with players going down like nine-pins throughout the season. Now, we've done the warm-up season, time to get on with winning a flag in a season that doesn't have to be referred to under weird numbers like 'Season 7' or 'Spring'.

2026 Daisy Pearce Medal votes
5 - Tyla Hanks
4 - Ryleigh Wotherspoon
3 - Megan Fitzsimon
2 - Maeve Chaplin
1 - Sarah Lampard

Apologies to Ebert, Gillard, Harris, and Hore

Leaderboard
Anyone with a financial investment in Purcell winning the big one would have been shattered by her withdrawal (but should also take special notice of the number for Gambling Helpline), and Hanks' latest top performance leaves her with a near unassailable lead. There's still hope for Olivia backers, but with a maximum of 20 votes available from four finals, everyone else is officially stuffed. No changes in the other awards, except for rumours of a Supreme Court challenge by a pro-Gillard faction.

41 - Tyla Hanks
32 - Olivia Purcell
--- Gorn ---
20 - Maeve Chaplin (LEADER: Defender of the Year)
16 - Tahlia Gillard
12 - Kate Hore, Ryleigh Wotherspoon
9 - Jordyn Allen (PROVISIONAL WINNER: Rising Star Award), Mia Austin
7 - Tayla Harris, Eliza McNamara
6 - Megan Fitzsimon
3 - Alyssa Bannan, Georgia Campbell (LEADER: Ruck of the Year)
1 - Shelley Heath-Barker, Aoife Horisk, Sarah Lampard

Goal of the Week
It must be Wotherspoon, and I enjoyed it so much that despite the lack of context in the final quarter of a flat game, I'm promoting it to the clubhouse leader for the season. And if you don't like it, Wotherfork off. 

Next week
The big Stinear reunion is on, with a Preliminary Final on the non-North side of the draw for the winner. The emergence of former MFC fringe forward Jacqueline Parry as one of the league's top goalkickers fits into the theme that all our exes live in Geelong, as do rumours that Fitzsimon is heading for a reunion with the old boss next year. Hopefully they can bond over memories of her absolutely extracting the piss from his side in a Qualifying Final.

This should have been Geelong's home game (if you assume the AFL would've let them play there), but we got away with it because Kardinia Park was already booked for a motorbike wankfest. Instead, it's off to Princes Park at the marquee time of 1.10pm. People say it's because Channel 7 don't want to show the games in prime time, but they've spent months doing that for pissy home and away games, and presumably if there's any more blood to be squeezed from the viewing audience, it'll come from showing important games between the best sides in the competition. Obviously not, and we're into part A) of a weird finals double header.

Unless there's midweek injury drama (and who could rule it out?), Campbell, Paxman and Purcell will be back. Which helps, but I suspect a lot of the action will be in whether we can hold the Cats off from scoring a shitload, while taking our own opportunities. Which is about the blandest match preview that could ever be written, but I legitimately have NFI what's going to happen.  

Final thoughts
Let rip with the real stuff.